next up previous
Next: A non-differentiable function with Up: Third semester calculus Previous: A function without a

A function with a single critical point, which is a local minimum but not a global minimum

For a function of a single variable f(x), if f is continuous on an interval I, has only one critical point in I, and that critical point is a local minimum, then it is the absolute (or global) minimum. However, for functions of more than one variable things are not so nice.

Let tex2html_wrap_inline585 . This is differentiable for all (x,y). In looking for critical points, we solve


The only point solving both of these equations is (0,1), and the second derivative test shows that this point is a local minimum for f. However, f(0,-3)=-17<f(0,1)=-1, so that this local minimum is not an absolute minimum. Here's a picture:


(The way I constructed this example was by starting with tex2html_wrap_inline595 , which has a local minimum at (1,1) and a saddle point at (0,0), and then sent the saddle point off to infinity by replacing x by tex2html_wrap_inline603 .)

Henry Wente (of the University of Toledo) has given me a polynomial with the same property: tex2html_wrap_inline605 , which he found in the Math Monthly, vol. 100, no. 3, March 1993. The article is ``Counting Critical Points of Real Polynomials in 2 Variables", by Durfee et. al., pp. 255-271.

Tom Vogel
Mon May 5 12:53:33 CDT 1997